ATTN: PBBM & Friends #Gifts

In the beginning I didn’t think it was worth blogging about just because it seemed open-and-shut : the prez is immune from suit until he steps down from office AND there’s no chance that the House of Reps would impeach him meanwhile.

But this sum-up from Michael Henry LI. Yusingco, lawyer and research fellow at the Ateneo Policy Center, cited in Business World‘s “Analysts: Marcos may have violated law with Duran Duran birthday bash”, changed my mind.

Yusingco … said Section 7 of the Code of Conduct and Ethical Standards for Public Officials [RA 6713] provides that public officials and employees “shall not solicit or accept, directly or indirectly, any gift, gratuity, favor, entertainment, loan or anything of monetary value from any person in the course of their official duties or in connection with any operation being regulated by, or any transaction which may be affected by the functions of their office.”

Presidential Decree No. 46, a decree signed by no less than Mr. Marcos’s father and namesake, states that it is punishable for any public official or employee, whether of the national or local governments, to receive directly or indirectly, and for private persons to give, or offer to give, any gift, present or other valuable thing on any occasion. “Even if presidential immunity takes precedence in this case, that argument must still be made,” Mr. Yusingco said in an e-mail. “At this point, the wrong that needs to be corrected goes beyond what is provided by law.”

“It’s all about doing the right thing in the context of our problems with patronage politics, graft and corruption, and bureaucratic inefficiencies.” [bold mine]
https://www.bworldonline.com/editors-picks/2024/09/17/622180/analysts

It’s definitely an “ATTENTION: PBBM & Friends” moment — just in case they truly didn’t know that the law prohibits private citizens from giving costly gifts to the President AND prohibits the President from accepting such gifts, simply, plainly, because such gifts are a kind of bribery, a way of currying favor with him for some future high position or huge contract or mining concession or tax exemption or land reclamation or flood control project — sky’s the limit on corrupt deals upholding the personal-private rather than the public interest.

Of course it is quite possible that PBBM and his billionaire friends KNEW that gifting the prez with Duran Duran Live! — believed to have cost around a million US dollars — is against the law but went ahead anyway either because (1) they were naive enough to think that they could keep it under wraps or (2) they were feeling invincible, beyond the reach of the law, as the OG Marcos and his cronies were?

Which might explain why the invite to “PBBM @67” kindly asked guests to “keep the vibes cozy and private” …. “skip the photos and videos” … “if possible, leave your phone in the car” … “or check it in at the reception desk” … “make this night extra special and intimate.” https://www.facebook.com/

News of Duran Duran LIVE! leaked out anyway, thanks, it is rumored, to sis Imee who gate-crashed, snapped a photo of the band performing, and sent it to a DDS vlogger based in China who posted about it on Facebook, claiming that the band was flown in using public funds and urging the public to go and join the fun.

The very next day the Palace denied the use of public money: the band was a gift of “old friends” …  “at no cost to the government”.  Besides, it was a welcome surprise at the end of a hard day’s work (distributing a total of P3.19 billion in government aid to the provinces).

Pundits had a field day dissing the Palace response.

One said the Palace shouldn’t have dignified the Duran Duran buzz with an official statement. Really? As though there was no alleged wrong-doing that had to be denied or justified?

One said that the prez should not have indulged Duran Duran & friends with his presence, he should have snubbed the event. But what if he was truly surprised?  What was he to do then — walk out of the event? Leave, and disappoint, family and friends to party without him, the celebrant?  Medyo unthinkable that BBM, or anyone, is capable of that.

The best responses yet — because law-abiding na, doable pa — came from Ronald Llamas and Winnie Monsod. Puwede kasing  naganap ang Duran Duran Live! event without controversy, or puwedeng na-damage control agad nang maayos.

Akbayan activist Llamas is all over the place these days, apparently the favorite political pundit of today’s crop of eager beaver podcasters. Sorry I can’t find the video, possibly with Christian Esguerra or Richard Heydarian or Politiskoop or Storycon (if not all of the above), where he pointed out that the ONLY ones who are allowed to gift PBBM with expensive gifts are members of his immediate family.

According to RA 6713 Section 3d, that means only the spouse and children below age 18 (RA6713 Sec3d). So if it had been the First Lady pala who had spent for Duran Duran or who would spend for the next surprise, no problem. Good to know.

Say naman ni Prof. Winnie Monsod on Cielo Magno‘s “Usapang Korupsyon”:

Who would be stupid enough to give a gift [of that magnitude], unless they expect something in return. If not now, maybe later. …  If I were the president and I was surprised by that gift, obviously I could not possibly say, Go away, Duran Duran…  I would have to repay that person who gave me the gift, whatever he spent to give me Duran Duran. Obviously.  https://www.facebook.com/cielomagno/videos/1067077645425752

Oo nga. And I imagine that it’s not too late. Huwag lang sana sa confidential funds kukunin ang Php55 million or so. Good luck to us.

Alice & Cassandra

I was hoping to finish a post on that million-$ surprise birthday gift to the prez but was completely distracted by the QUAD hearing that saw Alice aka Guo Hua Ping and Cassandra Ong back in their hot seats in Congress.

While the girls continue to invoke their right against self-incrimination, the fact that they fled the country back in July has been taken, naturally, as sign of guilt in connection with POGOs and related crimes, from falsification of documents to human trafficking to money laundering.  alice-guo-timeline/story/

Nakaka-impress ang documented info that Senators Risa and Win, and now the QUAD Reps, are surfacing in the course of interrogations and interpellations. Great research work. Or have these files/dossiers long been in the gathering by, maybe, civil society stalwarts, or plain political operators — Pinoy, Chinoy, CIA, whatever — just waiting for the right time to share with legislators?  At may matrix na rin daw, a la Dutz back in EJK days, how audacious.

But the most intriguing of all are these two girls, who are such unlikely Pinays, neither ever having gone daw to regular school, and yet we would never have guessed, given the confident way they carry themselves, with good command of English and Tagalog, one even got elected Mayor of Bamban at 36 (maybe 32, depending on what year she was really born); the other at 24 is the Authorized Rep of the Porac POGO Lucky South 99, and also the girlfriend of Alice’s brother Wesley, whose Chinese name Alice doesn’t know daw, I can’t imagine why.

Kapani-paniwala tuloy ang suspicion ni Tony Lopez ng Philstar that Alice speaks the truth when she says she grew up in a farm. /farm-spies-and-romances

Alice of Bambanland is determined to wear the senators’ patience thin by simply lying, lying, lying. Yes, this is a 34-year-old woman raised in a farm – a spy farm. Her training is good. In the CIA farm, one learns about “explosives, booby traps, escape and evasion techniques, survival training and interrogation.”

Per Quora, spy farms indeed were farms which were commandeered during World War II, along with the farmhouses, and repurposed into training schools for spy officers. So when Alice Guo says “laki ako sa farm,” she just might be telling the senators the truth. In this light, hindi kaya Guo’s lawyers are also “laki sa farm?” They lie better than Guo herself.

So maybe the Chinese version of a spy farm, complete with a piggery whose pigs had to be protected from germs from the outside world, which Alice alleges is the reason she wasn’t allowed to leave the farm and go to regular school like ordinary Pinoy kids. Kahit wala pa namang swine fever dito noon.

Fast-forward to QUAD. When she said she would only name names in an executive session because of death threats, the Reps asked if she would name the Filipino officials who facilitated her July escape, among other amazing stunts. Her reply was very definite: no local officials involved. Which of course raised everyone’s eyebrows. And when allowed by the Reps to make a final statement re an executive session, she said she would be willing if the Reps promised to believe her, referring I think to her earlier insistence that she could only tell of what and who she knew and she truly didn’t know a lot.

Quad comm’s mandate is [to] conduct hearings into the possible connection between Philippine offshore gaming operations (POGOs) and illegal drugs, extrajudicial killings (EJKs) and human rights violations during the bloody war waged by the six-year Rodrigo Roa Duterte presidency. /farm-spies-and-romances

I find myself giving Alice the benefit of the doubt only in the matter of how much she knows about the larger operation. I can believe that she’s a low-level player in the POGO game — her handlers tell her only what she needs to know. But it doesn’t mean she’s an insignificant catch, not when she was rising, slowly but surely, in the political arena.

It was like she came out of nowhere in 2022 — BBM had never heard of her before she was elected Bamban mayor as an independent, besting the NPC candidate in a 7-way fight.  And take note: during the campaign she endorsed BBM and Sara but “Angat Buhay” PINK was her color. What was up with that?

In the run-up to her election in 2022, Guo flew to a campaign event in her helicopter (black with a pink stripe) while crowds were treated to a huge firework display and DJ set. theguardian.com/world/article/2024/aug/04/inside-mystery-alice-guo-missing-philippines-mayor

By the 3rd quarter of 2023, she had so impressed the DILG — Benhur Abalos, was that you? Ikaw talaga! — that she was awarded a Seal of Good Local Governance, which apparently qualified her to join the Nationalist People’s Coalition (NPC), the most sosyal of political parties founded by Danding Cojuangco. will-alice-guo-run-under-marcos-jr-slate-in-2025-elections-053

She has, of course, since been expelled from the party.

“The NPC will not tolerate any unlawful acts or any appearance of impropriety by its members that will undermine the principle of our party,” NPC President Vicente Sotto III said in a letter to Tarlac Gov. Susan Yap, the NPC provincial chairperson.
https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2024/06/24/2365131/alice-guo-expelled-npc-member

Sabi nga ni NPC-affiliated Ping Lacson sa X:
https://x.com/iampinglacson/status/1833087910851260596

The way Guo Hua’ping a.k.a Alice Guo was taking the senators for a ride during the hearing, she could be a trained and smart foreign spy who had already started to climb the ladder of the country’s political structure as an elected municipal mayor.

In the realm of possibilities, she could be a member of Congress who has access to highly classified information with national security implications.

Had PAOCC not exposed her illegal activities, what if, in the long term, she and her handlers, using money and/or influence, manage to get her appointed as DND secretary or National Security Adviser?

Paktaylo na tayo!

Indeed. That was a close call. Question is, how many more Alices and Cassandras are running around our political circles, if not already deeply highly embedded.

September surprises

THE MOST STUNNING was the Supreme Court decision, released on Wednesday the 4th of September, declaring void and unconstitutional a lease contract recognizing Marcos Sr. as the owner of a 57-hectare property in Paoay Ilocos Norte that includes the so-called “Malacañang of the North”.  The ruling, penned by Senior Associate Justice Marvic Leonen, noted that the land was never titled under the name of Marcos Sr.  https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/1980549/sc-junks-marcos-family-claim-on-paoay-land

Napaka-good news. Diyatat this Supreme Court is kabalikat ng people of the Philippines in the continuing struggle to recover ill-gotten wealth? Ang saya naman, kahit pa it could be more a matter of who appointed them — the Chief Justice and 12 Associate Justices are Digong appointees, and the two others are PNoy’s. Whatever. Okey na rin.  Let’s see how they will rule on any cases brought against the Dutertes. https://sc.judiciary.gov.ph/incumbent-justices/

TWO DAYS LATER came the happy arrest of the fugitive Alice a.k.a. Guo Hua Ping (who disappeared in July), fetched from Indonesia and brought “home” by DILG sec Benhur Abalos on Friday the 6th of Sept at 1:30 a.m. — masked up and grimly refusing to show her face on cam, in stark contrast to photos of the first meet-up of the two in Jakarta, where they were all smiles, complete with handshake and “Ikaw talaga”, and you couldn’t help wondering, what’s up with these two?

ANOTHER TWO DAYS LATER, on Sunday the 8th, there was the very laudable capture of fugitive Apollo Quiboloy, the appointed anak ng diyos  (in hiding since February) — but  PNP Gen. Nick Torre, in command of the two-week ops would not could not make kuwento about how and where it happened, the story was for Sec Abalos to tell daw, except that Abalos was in Dubai that day, and you couldn’t help wondering why you had to wait and hear the story from someone who wasn’t around naman when the heaven-appointed Quiboloy walked out of his lunggâ into the arms of earthly authorities. Abalos must have known that Torre was was all set to move in on the cornered Quiboloy. Akala niya matatagalan pa?

“I have to fly back to Manila tonight after this event to present him to the public in a press conference,” said Abalos, who also initially disclosed Quiboloy’s capture through a Facebook photo that he captioned: “Nahuli na po si Apollo Quiboloy (Quiboloy has been caught).” https://www.expatmedia.net/abalos-trip-dubai-cut-short-quiboloy-arrest/2024/09/

Tuloy, dahil di agad nakapagkuwento si Torre, namayagpag ang mga spin ng DDS — kesyo being caught or being arrested doesn’t mean he surrendered, kesyo hindi siya sa loob ng KOJC nahuli, kesyo sa AFP siya sumuko at hindi sa PNP, therefore napahiya si Gen. Torre, at kung anoano pa.

Pero hindi naman nakakagulat that Abalos wanted, needed, to take credit for the stupendous success of the two-week ops of the PNP that’s under the DILG. Surely, para makabawi sa Alice a.k.a. Guo Hau Ping fiasco — baka sakaling matabunan at makalimutan na natin? Fat chance, Sec. Ikaw talaga.

THE LATEST STUNNER on the AliceGHP front is courtesy of Ping Lacson.

In a Radyo 630 interview on Wednesday, September 11, former senator Panfilo Lacson cited information from a Filipino-Chinese friend – with contacts to the First Family – who was allegedly approached by Guo for help.

Lacson said Guo was willing to pay P1 billion to fix her legal woes with the Presidential Anti-Organized Crime Commission.

The Filipino-Chinese businessman did not help Guo with her request, Lacson clarified.

The former senator urged the intelligence community to look into Guo and her potential to be a national security risk because of her alleged use of her position as mayor to help a syndicate behind an illegal offshore casino. https://www.philstar.com/headlines/2024/09/12/2384735/guo-allegedly-offered-p1-billion-bribe-settle-legal-issues-ex-senator

Makes you wonder who she’s so afraid of, and who she’s protecting, other than herself, of course.  Kaabang-abang.

Can Quiboloy hide forever?

VP Sara doesn’t think Apollo Quibuloy is still in Davao City, that he has had enough time to think of leaving.

Personally, I think wala na siya dito sa Pilipinas. Ako, kung one guess, kung nasaan si Pastor Quiboloy, nasa langit.” https://mb.com.ph/2024/9/2/nasa-langit

By “langit” I assume that the VP doesn’t mean that the “Appointed Son of God” has died and joined his “Appointed Father” in KOJC heaven. I assume she means that Quiboloy is “in heaven” on earth, that is, just very happy to have  escaped to a safer place beyond the reach of the PNP.

The PNP, however, is certain that the fugitive pastor is still in the sprawling 30-hectare KOJC compound that holds more than 40 buildings, including a cathedral and a huge underground bunker, and that they are closing in on him, slowly but surely. Hopefully, the authorities are also watching, and/or have cut off, all avenues of escape so that he can’t do an Alice Guo, if he hasn’t yet.

He was indicted in the US for conspiracy to engage in sex trafficking by force, fraud, and coercion; sex trafficking of children; and bulk cash smuggling. A federal warrant was issued for his arrest on Nov. 10, 2021.

Meanwhile, the DOJ said it sees no legal impediment to the arrest of Quiboloy for violation of Republic Act (R.A.) No. 7610 or the “Anti-Child Abuse Law” after the Davao Regional Trial Court (RTC) issued a warrant of arrest against him last April 3 for sexual abuse of minors and maltreatment.

“The charges against Quiboloy are not simple. They involve serious and morally abhorrent offenses such as sexual assault of a minor and human trafficking,” (DOJ Sec) Remulla pointed out. https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1222218

The game plan seems to be to do a Ping Lacson, as in, go fugitive until proven innocent.

[KOJC Law Dean] ISRAELITO TORREON. It is … within [Quiboloy’s] right to insist on his innocence without facing the rigors of trial. Why will you require him to go to trial when he honestly believes that the case need not go to trial knowing that he is really innocent in the first place. That was done before by former Senator Panfilo Lacson when a Double Murder case was filed against him in the RTC Manila and warrants of arrest were issued against him. He went into hiding and only surfaced when the Court of Appeals nullified the warrants of arrest on February 3, 2011 (please read Dacer versus Lacson, June 8, 2011 SC Decision, 3rd division).

Further, in Pastor Apollo Quiboloy’s case there is also a threat to his life and there is also a clear danger of being extraordinarily rendered to the US because his detractors likewise filed trumped up charges against him there. https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php

But are the two cases even comparable? Unlike Lacson, Quiboloy is charged with multiple crimes in different courts here and in America. Clearing him of all charges could take forever. Unless, of course, he is counting on the Dutertes re-capturing power in 2028? He just has to hold out until then? Maybe even fund the campaign of some DDS candidates in 2025 for more allies in Congress?

In 2013, a press release from the office of Senator Loren Legarda tells of the weight of Quiboloy’s endorsement then.

Quiboloy’s endorsement means the votes of his more than six million followers not only in Davao City where his congregation is based but also in other parts of the country and abroad.

Legarda, for her part, said: “I thank Pastor Quiboloy and the leadership of the Kingdom of Jesus Christ for including me in the list of candidates that they are endorsing. This serves as a strong expression of support to the causes that I have been espousing and the programs that I plan to accomplish when I get reelected.”

Besides Legarda, also endorsed by Quiboloy were senatoriables Migz Zubiri, Chiz Escudero, Bam Aquino, Cynthia Villar, Grace Poe, Sonny Angara, Juan Ponce Enrile, Jr., JV Ejercito, Nancy Binay, Edward Hagedorn, and Richard Gordon. https://legacy.senate.gov.ph/press_release/2013/0510_legarda3.asp

Nota bene. In 2010 Quiboloy endorsed Gibo Teodoro and Mar Roxas, but they both lost to PNoy and Jojo Binay. In 2016 he endorsed Duterte and Cayetano; the latter lost to Leni Robredo.

Read also Tita C. Valderama‘s “The Curious Case of Apollo Quiboloy.”

In the 2022 elections, Quiboloy’s endorsement was not as sought after as in past elections in view of his indictment in the U.S. and the issuance of a warrant for his arrest in November 2021.

Even then, the self-styled pastor endorsed the tandem of Ferdinand Marcos Jr. and Sara Duterte for president and vice president, respectively.

But on Feb. 21, Quiboloy asked Marcos to resign, accusing him of conniving with the U.S. government to get him arrested and killed. He said he had gone into hiding because his life was in danger.

A week later, Marcos advised Quiboloy to come out, face the congressional inquiries into the allegations of abuses against him and the KOJC and seize the opportunity “to say his side of the story.”

“Hindi na kami kompiyansa sa gobyernong ito. Gagawa at gagawa sila ng paraan para kami ay bigyan ng kasalanan,” said Quiboloy, raising the possibility that the Marcos administration would resort to the planting of evidence to implicate him in criminal activities.

… He claimed that the government would “take over all our properties” and establish a corporation under which the KOJC assets would fall under. In what appeared as a preemptive move, Quiboloy appointed Durterte last Friday as administrator of the properties belonging to KOJC.

That was last March 9 when Dutz was appointed admin. Five months later, August 5, the Anti-Money Laundering Council (AMLC) asked the Court of Appeals to freeze Quiboloy’s assets. The CA obliged on August 7, with a 20-day freeze order on Quiboloy’s bank accounts and real estate properties after finding merit in the sexual exploitation, human trafficking, and financial smuggling cases filed against Quiboloy and four others.

The Aug. 6 freeze order, which is effective immediately, covers Quiboloy’s 10 bank accounts with Banco De Oro and Metropolitan Bank and Trust Co. and seven real estate properties located in Davao del Norte, Davao City, Davao Oriental, Mati, and Roxas City. The freeze includes five vehicles and one private plane owned by the fugitive pastor.

Also ordered frozen were 47 bank accounts, 16 real properties in the provinces of Laguna, Davao del Norte, Davao Oriental and Iloilo, and Quezon City and the cities of Davao, Tagbilaran, Mandaue, and Butuan, and 16 vehicles of KJC.

This also freezes SMNI’s 17 bank accounts, five real estate properties (located in Cagayan, Isabela, and Cabanatuan and Makati cities), and 26 vehicles.

August 20, the freeze on Quiboloy’s bank accounts and properties was extended six months, until February 2025. That’s some three months before midterm elections. Enough time to influence the outcome, kahit konti? But does it mean there’s a chance that Quiboloy would be cleared of all charges by then and that he could therefore come out of hiding and openly endorse DDS candidates? Parang not likely.

And then again, who knows, ang dami pang puwedeng mangyari. There’s still the China card at play. Surely the Dutertes’ allies overseas (nandoon na kaya si Quibs?) are watching closely and liking the idea of a Sara-Digong tandem in 2028.  Ang problema na lang nila, kung paano makakaraos through the next three years without losing any more ground to the Marcos-Romualdez cabal.

As for us on the sidelines who are not enamored of either Marcos or Duterte and can only watch the two camps tear each other down, the challenge I believe is to turn 2028 into a serious three-cornered fight. But that’s for another blog.

*

Will the Dutertes have their vengeance?
https://opinion.inquirer.net/176586/will-the-dutertes-have-their-vengeance

Inside ‘son of God’ cult leader Apollo Quiboloy’s sprawling underground lair with rooms for ‘most attractive sex slaves’ – as cops scour Philippines compound for preacher on FBI Most Wanted list for sex crimes https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-13787593/apollo-quiboloy-bunker-compound-philippines-sex-slaves-cult.html

I miss being in a Cult. https://www.reddit.com/r/OffMyChestPH/comments/1axauod/i_miss_being_in_a_cult/

Why a Filipino Megachurch Founder Is on the Run, Claiming the U.S. Wants Him Dead https://time.com/6722170/apollo-quiboloy-fbi-us-philippines/